One or the Other

The White Sox showed resilience yesterday, that, or a dead-cat bounce. Either way, they defeated the Tigers 3-1 in front of nearly 31,000 fans who didn’t mind rearranging their Saturday plans when the game time was switched from evening to afternoon in order to beat the approaching rain. Sean Burke pitched six effective innings of one-run ball. Noah Schultz (!) and Grant Taylor provided three shutout innings to seal the victory. Miguel Vargas was the offense. Vargas drew a two-out walk in the first, stole second base and scored the first run of the game on a duck snort to left by Munetaka Murakami. Vargas’ 33rd homerun of the season led off the sixth inning, giving the Sox a two-run lead after Sam Antonacci’s sacrifice fly in the fifth. Did I mention Vargas also made at least one run-saving play at third reminiscent of Robin Ventura and Joe Crede? Unless something changes drastically and suddenly, the Sox will sink or swim (or bounce) depending what Vargas does over the next seven games. Murakami along with Braden and Colson Montgomery are just too far gone right now to be of much help. Whatever Antonacci, Andrew Benintendi and Chase Meidroth can bring to the plate would be greatly appreciated. I’d include Tristan Peters to the list, if it weren’t for Peters crashing into the fence Friday night chasing down Kevin McGonigle’s triple. Day to day, as they say. If only the Sox had the luxury of time. They don’t.

Collapse

The White Sox blew an 8-2 lead to the Tigers last night, losing 11-8, which puts them a full game behind the Guardians for first place in the AL Central and leaves them just one game ahead of the Rangers for the final playoff spot. So, what did Sox manager Vibes Venable do? Compliment the Tigers, of course. Oh, and he also went into his talking-box-score routine, stating the obvious to anyone who can read or see what happened. It’s the “why” behind a loss that trips Venable up. Why did rookie starter David Sandlin lose it all at once in the fifth? No answer. Why did Sean Newcomb and Bryan Hudson give up a combined five runs in the eighth? No answer, though I have one. It’s called “overwork.” Newcomb and Hudson have pitched a combined 151.1 innings so far this season. Live by the opener, and, eventually, you die by the bullpen. Oh, and why did the final fourteen Sox hitters go down in a row? Because happy talk is no substitute for leadership.

A Pulse

Munetaka Murakami and the White Sox both showed a pulse last night at the Rate, beating Detroit 3-1 on a Murakami three-run homer in the first inning, after which pitching and defense dominated. Starter Erick Fedde did the Houdini thing through 4.2 innings. Fedde gave up one run on four hits, two walks and a hit-by-pitch, stranding six Tigers’ baserunners along the way. Smoke, mirrors, guile, Fedde is doing something right. Last night, so did the defense. Left fielder Randal Grichuk saved Fedde a run in the fifth by barehanding a ball off the fence to keep Gleyber Torres to a single; Dillon Dingler followed with what would’ve been a run-scoring double. Grichuk also threw out Spencer Torkelson in the sixth when Torkelson tried to take an extra base on a single. The best play of the night, though, may have belonged to Murakami. With a runner on first and two out in the eighth, Mark Clark hit an infield single, beating the throw from third baseman Miguel Vargas. Brett Callahan, the lead runner, kept going and was called safe at third despite a strong throw across the diamond by Murakami. Sox manager Vibes Venable challenged the call, which was overturned upon review. I should also mention here Murakami collected his first MLB triple in the eighth. Which leads us to the bad news, such as it was. The Sox failed on two chances to score that insurance run. And Grant Taylor was scary. Yes, he went 2.1 innings for the save, but he put the tying runs on in the ninth. Lucky for Taylor that Vargas managed a 5-3 double play, with a tag of the runner going to third coupled with a strong throw to first. Now to see if Murakami can continue hitting—and if Braden Montgomery can break out of his slump. Montgomery went 0-for-3 batting ninth last night. The rookie has got to hit for his team to advance.

Sowing and Reaping

The White Sox were hanging on to a 3-2 in the bottom of the sixth inning against the Guardians in their rubber match yesterday afternoon. That’s when Sox manager Vibes Venable brought in Sean Newcomb in relief of Hagen Smith, two on and two out. Newcomb served up a three-run homerun to rookie Petey Halpin, who came into the game batting .210. So much for the lefty-lefty advantage that should’ve broken Newcomb’s way. Wait, there’s more. Newcomb walked the next two batters before giving up a run-scoring double to Jose Ramirez. The line on Newcomb read four batters faced; two walks; two extra-base hits; two inherited runners scoring; and two runs allowed. What happened? Newcomb said after the game, “I haven’t been myself. Just not being super crisp, hitters being more in tune with what I’m doing.” [today’s Sun-Times] Gosh, do you think Newcomb is a little gassed from pitching 10.2 innings in six appearances as an opener? Perish the thought. Damn’ the torpedoes, full closers ahead! It seems Hagen Smith was gassed, too, trying to go two innings again. Maybe instead of pulling Anthony Kay after four, Venable should’ve seen how long his starter could go. If Chase Meidroth hadn’t committed an error trying to make a tag in the third, Kay would’ve gone four scoreless innings. If Venable was going to roll the dice on Smith (he allowed the move was “debatable”), it should’ve been back on Sunday, against Alec Burleson in St. Louis. But what do I know? I think dropping two of three in Cleveland makes it hard, if not impossible, to win the division. Not Venable, who told reporters after the game, “We knew that this series wasn’t going to define the rest of the year for us. Giving up the division lead, everybody will feel how they feel about it. But I’m proud of the guys and I think we’re in a good spot moving forward.” [from today’s story on team website] Proud of a team that lost a crucial, even defining, series? Not my bowl of word salad.

Maybe, Maybe Not

Maybe the White Sox were fated to lose 7-6 last night on an opposite-field, two-out, two-run, walk-off double on a 0-2 pitch from Grant Taylor to Brayan Rocchio. Or maybe not. I wonder because three moves by Sox manager Vibes Venable put his team in a bad spot to win, starting with his choice of opener. That would be Chris Murphy, who, in his previous appearance, gave up a bases-clearing double that sent the Sox down to defeat in St. Louis on Sunday. Murphy was no better in Cleveland, giving up two homeruns to the Guardians in the first. The Sox were down 3-0 by the time Murphy exited with two outs in the bottom of the first inning. But you have to give credit where credit is due; the Sox climbed back to take a 6-4 lead in the sixth inning. Davis Martin pitched well, giving up one earned run in 5.1 innings of work, while the usual heroes came through to provide the lead. I’m talking about you in particular, Chase Meidroth and Miguel Vargas. And I could be talking about Sam Antonacci and Tristan Peters, too. But not Jake Rogers. Venable had Rogers start behind the plate for the right-lefty advantage against Guardians’ starter Foster Griffin. Rogers responded with an 0-for-2 effort, putting his White Sox BA at a microscopic .111 (4-for-36). Thankfully, Kyle Teel replaced Rogers and walked twice, the first walk coming around to score in the sixth inning. Venable also continued his unfathomable loyalty to Munetaka Murakami, who struck out four times batting cleanup. In his last four games, Murakami has struck out eleven times. He’s batting .094 over his last fifteen games and .110 over his last 30. This can’t go on. Unless not making the postseason is part of GM Chris Getz’s plan.

See Ball, Feel Ball

It was the single most important at-bat for the White Sox this season to date. Centerfielder Tristan Peters fouled off twelve pitches from Guardians’ starter Gavin Williams before managing an eighteen-pitch walk with nobody out and Andrew Benintendi on second base in the top of the sixth inning last night in a scoreless ballgame. Wait, there’s more. The next batter, Colson Montgomery, grounded a ball to first baseman Nathaniel Lowe, who threw to second for a potential 3-6-3 double play. Only Lowe hit Peters in the back of the head. The ball bounced off Peters’ helmet into centerfield, allowing Benintendi to score and Peters to move to third base, the start of a six-run inning in a 7-3 Sox win that extends their lead over the Guardians’ to 1-1/2 games. Kudos to Kyle Teel for his two-run double and Miguel Vargas for a two-run homerun. Ditto Sean Newcomb; Sean Burke; Hagen Smith; and Trevor Richards for not allowing an earned run all night. Now, for the brickbats. Munetaka Murakami struck out three times, along with Colson and Braden Montgomery. Colson Montgomery allowed a run to score in the sixth on his second error in two games while a throwing error by Vargas in the ninth made possible a homer by David Fry that shouldn’t have happened. Sloppy defense does not win games. As Tristan Peters knows, heady play does. That, and a good eye.

Why

The White Sox lost 3-1 to the Cardinals yesterday because Luis Castillo pitched on Saturday. Here’s why. Saturday, Sox manager Vibes Venable went the opener route, figuring the odds were Castillo wasn’t going to give him much. That meant 1.1 innings for opener Sean Newcomb before Castillo labored through 2.2 innings. Hagen Smith followed with two innings; then Grant Taylor with 1.2 innings; Jordan Hicks, .1 inning; and Bryan Hudson, one inning. In other words, Venable needed five good relievers in various roles to get the win, blessed be the name of Randal Grichuk. Yesterday, rookie David Sandlin did everything that GM Chris Getz thought he’d be getting from Castillo when he acquired the veteran righty at the trade deadline, and then some. Sandlin set down the first sixteen St. Louis batters he faced before giving up two one-out singles in the sixth inning. Rather than panic, Sandlin struck out Bryan Torres. That made it two on, two out for a righty-right matchup against Ivan Herrera. Sandlin did his job, inducing a hard groundball to shortstop Colson Montgomery, who booted it. (Not to worry. Venable covered for Montgomery in the postgame, baserunner Nathan Church apparently screening Montgomery just long enough to cause the miscue.) That brought up lefthanded-hitting Alec Burleson, at the time sitting on 106 RBIs. Venable chose to lift his starter. But who do you bring in? All the best lefty relievers pitched not even 24 hours earlier. Smith, with 29 strikeouts in 20 innings, would have been the best option if he hadn’t already gone two innings. And maybe he was the best option, if only to get one out. Venable opted for lefty Chris Murphy. Not quite lions vs. Christians, but Burleson still cleared the bases with a double to right. Montgomery had a chance to redeem himself with two out in the top of the ninth and the bases loaded, but he flied out to shallow centerfield. It shouldn’t have come to that. Because of Luis Castillo, it did.