Ball of Confusion

My God, this White Sox team is confusing. Colson Montgomery had another o-fer night (0-for-5); Jose Urquidy in his Sox debut (three runs, five hits in 3.2 innings of work) made me think fondly of Erick Fedde; and Drew Romo lowered his BA to a pretty microscopic .132. All that, and they still beat the Tigers in Detroit last night, 9-5. What gives? Well, it helped that Tristan Peters and Braden Montgomery both showed signs of life at the plate, with three hits apiece. Peters socked a two-run homer while Montgomery countered with a two-run triple. More, please. Miguel Vargas also looked to be breaking out of his slump with a four-hit effort, including two homers. Like Peters, Vargas had himself a two-run homer, and, like Munetaka Murakami, a solo shot. More dingers with runners on base, please. Now what? Well, one game at a time and all that. Plus a quality start from Anthony Kay. Please.

Wait Till Next Year

Two years ago, the White Sox went 41-121 while improving to 60-102 last season. Right now, their record stands at 62-58. That may be all the miracle a Sox fan can expect or ask for as their team battles for a division title (and how odd to write those words). Take yesterday afternoon’s 9-8 loss to the Reds (please). Davis Martin stunk, again; Colson Montgomery and Miguel Vargas both went 0-for-5; Braden Montgomery looks like he’s getting batting tips from the 0-fers; and somewhere manager Vibes Venable made the obvious obvious in his postgame comments. If you believe Bleacher Report and USA Today, the White Sox have the eighth-best minor-league system in all of baseball, and I think those rankings are erring on the side of caution. The team has middle infielders everywhere to go with some intriguing outfield and catching prospects plus enough pitching to keep me wondering how Erick Fedde stays employed. Speaking of which, if I were Davis Martin… Ex-GM Rick Hahn missed a chance to reset the Sox roster both after the 2021 and 2022 seasons. Yoan Moncada and Eloy Jimenez could have brought sizable returns while the team pivoted to young players like Gavin Sheets and Jake Burger. Instead, we got systemic collapse. Current GM Chris Getz now finds himself in the same situation. He has a left fielder (Sam Antonacci) who looks great when he moves to second base and a second baseman (Chase Meidroth) who can play a very nice shortstop. Plus Getz has a system full of middle infielders, starting with Roch Cholowsky, Caleb Bonemer and Billy Carlson. Something’s got to give, not this season but next. That, or Epic Collapse 2.0.

Oops

I didn’t mean to peak; it just happened. The White Sox beat the Reds 5-0 last night on a combined two-hitter from Luis Castillo (seven innings); Hagen Smith (one inning, three strikeouts); and Huascar Brazoban (one uneventful inning). Pitching is everything. Without it, you have today’s score of Reds 8 Sox 4 in the top of the fifth. Better to focus on the past. I mean, how often does Drew Romo get two hits in a game, including a homerun, along with two RBIs? Chase Meidroth also homered, number twelve, to go with 48 RBIs. In the minors, Meidroth never hit more than nine homers or drove in more than 57 runs. How do you spell “success”? Plus Sam Antonacci had three hits. Too bad he and Meidroth don’t pitch.

What Marvin Gaye Said

A game like last night’s ten-inning, 5-4 White Sox loss to the Reds makes me want to holler; a less mature version would also throw things. Here’s why. The Sox hit three homeruns—all solo shots—to go with seven innings of one-run ball from starter Sean Burke, everything wasted when Cincinnati scored three runs in the eighth to tie the game at four. Manager Vibes Venable thought he could bring in Bryan Hudson to retire three right-hand hitters, two of them switch hitters. Nope. All three singled. Things might have improved with Grant Taylor replacing Hudson, but they didn’t. Taylor was off, that or in love with his slow, breaking stuff. Runners moved up to second and third on a deep-enough flyball to right field on an 87.6 mph slider out over the lower corner of the plate. Taylor then walked a batter before yielding a two-run single to Tyler Stephenson. Did Stephenson hit Taylor’s best pitch? Not unless an 85.1 mph curveball on the outer half of the plate counts. After that, it was just a matter of time. The Reds’ bullpen has the fifth-worst ERA in baseball. How odd that Cincinnati relievers retired eighteen of nineteen batters faced. After the game, Venable said the three softly-hit balls off of Hudson were “[j]ust baseball” and “just part of the game.” [online story in today’s Tribune] What a crock and dodge of responsibility. Venable put in a reliever who left the ball over the plate to three straight batters. Exit velo has nothing to do with it. Did I mention Colson Montgomery struck out three times in an 0-for-4 night? On the year, Montgomery is hitting .213 with 157 strikeouts over 473 plate appearance. In other words, he’s striking out 33 percent of the time. Tell me how you win a division with numbers like that.

Retirement

Ex-White Sox shortstop Tim Anderson made his retirement official yesterday in a Zoom call with Chicago media. The 33-year old, onetime face of the franchise gave voice to joy; sadness; and, possibly, regret during his video announcement. It made me think of my daughter. Unlike Anderson, Clare knew when her career would end; most female athletes do. Every sport has its season. When the calendar runs out after senior year, the playing and competing end, except for a lucky few who play professionally. Was my then 22-year old any less emotional than Anderson yesterday? Probably not; she just did a better job hiding it, what with graduation and graduate school following in the wake of Senior Day. But I’m sure there were moments when she felt a void. Clare had been hitting a ball since before she was four. Anderson mentioned some business ventures along with the challenge of being a father and husband. If he’s anything like my daughter, he’ll find meaning, and perhaps a little joy, in teaching the game he once played.

Heaven-sent

Things looked bleak for the South Side Nine on a Sunday afternoon, Davis Martin their starting pitcher. The pride of Abilene continued his bad habit of late, for the third straight game letting the other side score right out of the gate. This the visitors from Cleveland did twice, only to let the home team cut the lead in half thanks to a double off the bat of that Man from Japan. Then the heavens opened up, and the rain did pour. Not a pitch was thrown for one hour, then two, plus another 23 minutes or so. When it came time to resume, the vibing Venable pointed to rookie Hagen Smith and said, off, my boy, to the mound you go. White Sox 5 Guardians 3. Smith was what you might call effectively wild, striking out three in the second while walking a batter before walking the bases loaded in the third. One line drive to third baseman Miguel Vargas later, Smith not only escaped the jam of his own making, he set himself up for the win. That’s because the Sox scored four in the bottom of the third, three on a Colson Montgomery laser over the wall in right. Montgomery said later he was taking stock of things, offering that, “Success, it leaves clues.” [story today on team website] Yes, grasshopper, it does. Now, make like Sherlock, and figure them out. For reasons best known to himself, Manager Vibes used reliever Trevor Richards for the third time in four games. The overuse showed in the ninth when Richards gave two walks along with two wild pitches, leading to a run on a sacrifice fly by Jose Ramirez. Rookie righthander Tanner McDougal, brought up along with Smith from Triple-A Charlotte, was warming in the bullpen, just in case. For that, I can’t wait. Honestly.

Better

Well, White Sox manager Vibes Venable managed to keep track of mound visits last night, and his team capitalized on a reservoir of emotion following the retirement of Ozzie Guillen’s number 13 to stop a four-game losing streak. Sox 6 Guardians 3. Before I forget, a tip of the cap to starter Anthony Kay for another solid performance (two earned runs in six innings) and GM Chris Getz for going out and signing the 31-year old lefthander, who had spent the two previous seasons pitching in Japan. At 9-5, Kay has pitched like anything but a journeyman with four career wins going into 2026. Chase Meidroth had two more RBIs, as did Tristan Peters. The former Savannah Banana is showing signs of breaking out of a horrendous month-long slump. If so, it couldn’t happen at a better time.

Speaking of Dunce Caps

White Sox manager Vibes Venable donned the dunce cap in the top of the first inning against the Guardians last night when he left the dugout to visit starter Noah Schultz after a two-run single put the visitors up by two and threatening for more. Somehow, Venable missed that pitching coach Zach Bove had already made a visit after Schultz hit Jo Adell to load the bases. And Venable has a bench coach why, again? Sadly, there’s more in this 8-2 loss. Venable brought in David Sandlin, just called up from Charlottee, and the 25-year old righty did all that you could ask on short notice. Sandlin got out of the first without further damage and then kept Cleveland off the board through the fourth. Ah, but the fifth. That’s a different story requiring an even bigger dunce cap. Sandlin got Steven Kwan to ground out before giving up a single to Chase DeLauter. Did Venable think it was time to take out his pitcher? Nope. Ditto after Sandlin yielded a walk and then a hit-by-pitch. Maybe Venable was still in shock from his first-inning faux pas. Whatever the reason, not only did he stay in the dugout through all that but for Angel Martinez’s grand slam as well and two hits after that. What does this all mean? Heaven help the White Sox if the team takes on the personality of its manager, that’s what.

Enough

You know what I’ve had enough of? White Sox manager Vibes Venable complimenting the other team for beating his team. Venable did it again last night after the Red Sox came back a total of five time to tie the score—three times in extra innings—before pushing across the winning run in the thirteenth. Bad Sox 12 Good Sox 11. This was a game the White Sox needed and Venable managed away. He used everyone out of the bullpen except Sean Newcomb. Guess what? I would’ve used Newcomb and/or a starter to get the win. Chase Meidroth gave the Sox a two-run lead with a homer off Aroldis Chapman in the top of tenth, only for Venable to treat Trevor Richards like he was the second coming of Rollie Fingers. Richards gave back both runs, plus one in the eleventh. Instead of saying how good the Red Sox were, Venable could’ve put on a dunce cap. Same message.

Numbers Game

The Bad Sox had their way with the Good Sox last night, shutting out the visitors 4-0. Live by the long ball, die a whole bunch of other ways. Like the stolen base. Boston had three to our zero, and two of those set up runs. Not only did Drew Romo fail to throw out two would-be base stealers, he let one advance to third on a throwing error. Did I mention Romo went 0-for-2, dropping his average down to .132? Romo left it to his teammates to collect three singles and a lonely double. Ah, batting average. The White Sox rank seventh in all of baseball for homeruns, the Red Sox 24th. But Boston ranks twelfth in BA and fourteenth in OBP to 22nd and seventeenth for the White Sox. Did I mention the Red Sox have the third-best team ERA at 3.49 while the White Sox are thirteenth at 4.08? Let me channel my inner Hawk Harrelson here. (Ignore the shuddering.) The Carmines are on an incredible hot streak right now, going 30-5 since June 25. In baseball, it’s not only who you play but when you play them. Which is what all the numbers are pointing to.

Danger

Danger, Will Robinson! Danger! Davis Martin is pitching, and for some time now, that’s a bad thing, as evidenced by six first-inning runs at Fenway last night. Bad Sox 14 Good Sox 2. After the game, Martin said he may have been tipping pitches. What, that wasn’t happening in April and May, when he was 7-1 with a sub-2.00 ERA? All I know is he hasn’t gone a month since with an ERA under 5.68. It can’t all be attributed to tipping pitches. The 29-year old righthander has a 6.55 ERA over his last seven starts and 5.54 over his last fifteen. What gives? The analytics’ crew better get their gizmos out to find the answer. And quick.

Then and Now

When the trade deadline passed yesterday at 5 PM, the White Sox showed themselves to be astute buyers, acquiring catcher Joey Bart; reliever Huascar Brazoban; and outfielder Brenton Doyle. They join starter Luis Castillo, traded for over the weekend. GM Chris Getz was able to hang onto all his top prospects. Will it push the Sox over the top and into the postseason? We’ll have to wait to find out. All these names make me think of players acquired for pennant drives long ago: Ken Boyer; Smoky Burgess; Rocky Colavito; Jim King; Frank Lary; Moose Skowron. I remember them all, if not the World Series they were supposed bring along.

Power's Back On

The White Sox hit three homeruns yesterday, beating the Rays 9-1 behind some pretty good pitching from starter Anthony Kay. As ever, I should be happy, but— Will Colson Montogmery ever figure things out at the plate? Yesterday, Montgomey doubled with two out in the top of the first, which set up two runs, so, good that. Only he proceeded to strike out his next four at-bats to leave him batting .215 at the end of the day. Four strikeouts, oh my. Subtract one, and you’ll end up with three, just like catcher Drew Romo, whose 0-for-4 left him hitting a pretty miniscule .134. Would it even be mathematically possible for Romo to get his BA to Montgomery’s .215? Right now, lack of production from behind the plate makes it look like the Sox are playing without a DH in the lineup. And I can think of some Sox pitchers of yore who could hit better, as in Gary Peters and Juan Pizarro. But a win’s a win, and the Sox took the series, two games to one. Now, it’s on to Boston, where I really, really like to see our Sox beat those Sox.

Power Outage

The problem with big-power/low batting-average teams is feast-or-famine syndrome. Friday night, the White Sox hit four homeruns and won. Yesterday afternoon, they managed all of five singles and lost. Rays 1 Sox 0. The silver lining is that Noah Schultz pitched five innings of one-run ball. The Tall One scattered three singles while striking out four and walking no one. Schultz was also pretty efficient, throwing just—for him—67 pitches. The question now is, what becomes of the 22-year old lefty in the wake of the Sox trading for starter Luis Castillo? Bullpen? Back to Charlotte? Tune in, and, while you’re at it, read all the “experts” who think the Sox gave up too much for the 33-year old righthander. All of a sudden, ex-Sox Seranthony Dominguez has a value beyond his 3.99 ERA and five blown saves. Yes, I would’ve liked to hold onto catching prospect Boston Smith (what a name), but what were the odds of Smith leapfrogging from Double-A to take over from Kyle Teel and company anytime soon? In my book, it was a trade worth making. Time will tell.

Slug/Pop

“Slug” is how ballplayers and coaches refer to power these days. I prefer “pop,” if only because a little dweeb who turned into my brother-in-law would run around the kitchen of his house, yelling “Doug the Slug! Doug the Slug!” when I came to pick up his sister for a date. Some things are hard to let go of. But if the White Sox want to talk about team “slug,” that’s fine with me, as long as they keep getting results like last night’s 6-1 win over the Rays at Tropicana Field. Miguel Vargas; Andrew Benintendi; Munetaka Murakami; and Colson Montgomery all homered off Rays’ starter Nick Martinez, who had a 10-2 record with a 2.45 ERA entering the game. And there wasn’t a cheap one in the bunch. Eight hits on the night, four homeruns and four singles, plus two walks. Two of the homers were solo shots, the other two two-run bombs. Odd, like saying the offense is hitting on “all five [cylinders].” Murakami and Benintendi also collected singles, which pushes each of them to .250, my Mendoza Line for sluggers, if you will. Like I said, they can call it whatever they want, as long as they keep getting results.

Walk-off Walk

Talk about temptation. I had breakfast on Lincoln Avenue this morning, Yankees’ fans seated behind me and alongside; the guy closest to me was definitely confusing his fork with a shovel. How do I know they were Yankees’ fans? Let’s just say they made certain fashion statements that, given their advanced age, were hard to miss. What I wanted to say, but refrained from, was: You guys on the East Coast sure play a sloppy brand of baseball. One game, your catcher lets in the tying runs with two outs in the bottom of the eleventh by throwing a pickoff throw—at third base, mind you—down the third-base line. Next game, a hitter overslides third base on a double and your reliever is walking in the winning run on four straight pitches to someone who’s five for his last 47 at-bats. But that’s what Fernando Cruz did to Tristan Peters yesterday afternoon. Sox 2 Yankees 1 in eleven innings. And now for a random observation. I mentioned channeling emotion into effective performance and how manager Vibes Venable denied Sam Antonacci that chance Wednesday night. Well, yesterday, Antonacci batted in the bottom of the eleventh and hit a ball that all but ate undressed baseman Ben Rice. Somehow, Rice kept the ball in front of him, denying Antonacci the walk-off hjit; instead, it turned into an infield single that helped set the stage for Peters. My point is, Antonacci was ready. I just hope Venable is tonight managing in St. Petersburg

I Should Be Happy, But—

The White Sox put themselves in a 4-0, first inning hole last night that Yankees’ starter Cam Schlitter only deepened by retiring seventeen of the first eighteen batters he faced. Then something happened. The Sox rallied to win 6-5 in twelve innings, thanks to a flare of a single off the bat of Edgar Quero. Still. The Sox tied the score at four with back-to-back homeruns from Sam Antonacci and Munetaka Murakami in the eighth. Two innings later, with a chance to win the game with a runner on third and one out, manager Vibes Venable pinch-hit for Antonacci to get a righty-lefty advantage. The move didn’t work as Randal Grichuk grounded out with the infield drawn in. Antonacci is hitting .200 against lefties, .300 against righties. The next batter, Murakami, is 195 against lefties and .260 vs. righties. But Venable didn’t pinch-hit for Murakami. Baseball is a game of emotions, as evidenced by Davis Martin’s performance. Martin gave up three hits and a walk in that first inning, only to settle down and throw five shutout innings during which time he scattered two singles and a walk. Good for him. Now I wonder, what happened? Odds are he channeled those emotions into an effective performance. Which was what Antonacci did with that homerun in the eighth, going 0-for-3 in his previous at-bats. Do you think that would’ve stopped all of a sudden because of the pitching matchup? We’ll never know. And neither will Venable.

Patience

It’s hard to be patient after enduring three straight seasons of the White Sox losing 100-plus games a year. Finally, they’re winning more than losing, and I want more. But how realistic is that? Nobody expected the Sox to be four games over .500 at the end of July. I could make an argument there isn’t one set position outside of right field, where Braden Montgomery plays. And yet a bunch of guys who may or may not be on the South Side have their team in first place in the AL Central, this despite losing again to the Yankees last night, 3-2. The game was not as close as the score might indicate. That’s because the Sox were shut out for 8.2 innings, when Chase Meidroth—keep at second, move to another position or trade?—hit a two-run homerun, bringing up Everson Pereira as a last hope. Need I say more? Anthony Kay had one bad inning that proved baseball truly is a game of inches. Tristan Peters almost made a great catch crashing into the wall in center field, Max Schuemann bounced a ball over a drawn-in infield. Instead of zero runs, it’s three runs. And, if the middle of the order doesn’t produce…Well, I’ve said enough about that. So, I’ll try to be patient and cross my fingers that the Sox can go last-to-first. But it would be silly to expect them to.

Blah

Where to start? Noah Schultz squandering a three-run lead? White Sox relievers coughing up six runs? Third-base coach Justin Jirschele sending a hobbled Colson Montgomery home on a throw that beat him, oh, by a good ten feet? Take your pick. It all adds up to a 9-5 loss to the Yankees. We’ll start with Schultz, who told reporters after the game he was “a little gassed out” by the time manager Vibes Venable pulled him in the top of the fourth inning. [story today on team website] So, how does a 22-year starter old get “gassed” if he only goes 3.1 innings? Oh, that’s right. He needed 72 pitches to get there. Not good, but a real incentive to find an alternative to Schultz the next time his turn comes up in the rotation. Hello, David Sandlin. As for the relief pitching, it’s always a crapshoot unless the stars align, the way they did in 2005. All a manager can do is juggle his streaky pitchers with his lockdown ones, trying to exploit the good streaks while minimizing the bad stretches and at the same time not burn out his go-to guys. In my book, Venable did everything right last night. He didn’t wait around for Schultz to implode and tried to get the right matchups with the relievers he brought in. It’s just that Chis Murphy, Bryan Hudson and Sean Newcomb looked intent on streaking the wrong way. As for Jirschele, stupid is as stupid does. Philosopher Gump knew that, and so did Barack Obama. The next time he gets a chance, the Sox third-base should look up exactly what the ex-President say about that.

A Day to Remember

We accompanied our grandson to his first-ever White Sox game yesterday afternoon, and I think he enjoyed himself in all the ways a kid should on such an august occasion. I mean, he wore a Munetaka Murakami shirt in honor of his favorite player; scored a Murakami bobblehead; and watched his hero hit a homerun in a 12-3 Sox romp. Leo missed Mune’s second homer of the day in the eighth inning, by which time he was asleep in the car on the way home. I saw it for him. Thank you, Erick Fedde for providing the perfect argument against spending big on a closer. Closers can’t close when there’s no lead to close on. And Fedde kept putting his team in the hole giving up the lead when given it. The desperation fourth—or fifth—starter gave up a leadoff homer to Jeremy Pena in the first, then let the Astros tie the game at two and three before manager Vibes Venable saw fit to pull him with one out in the fifth and one on. That’s three runs in 4.1 innings of work, for anyone keeping stats out there. If the Sox want to build something special, they need a minimum of two more quality starters. You rarely get those at the trade deadline, and never on the cheap. No, you’re better off to develop them; sign them as free agents; or swing big trades for them in the offseason. Right now, GM Chris Getz would be best off improving his roster around the edges and going with the team he constructed during spring training.