Wednesday, January 22, 2020

The Goldilocks' Challenge


The NFL selects 15 candidates for its hall of fame, baseball elects two (plus another two selected by a veterans’ committee).  The one sport lets too many in, the other too few.  What to do?

First off, a tip of the cap to Derek Jeter and, yes, Larry Walker for their election to Cooperstown, as announced yesterday.  Next, a question for the baseball establishment:  If football can put offensive linemen into Canton, why can’t baseball find a place in Cooperstown for the likes of Tommy John, Jim Kaat, Minnie Minoso, Billy Pierce…?  Not to take anything away from the Bears’ Jimbo Covert, though I’d like to see what his football WAR would be and how to compute it.
As for the other names mentioned here, like I said:  WAR, what is it good for?  And what’s a hall of fame without John, Kaat et al? 

No comments:

Post a Comment