Monday, November 24, 2014

The High Cost of Free Speech in Professional Sports


Last week, the NFL fined Seahawks’ running back Marshawn Lynch a total of $100,000 for refusing to talk with the media.  Apparently, it’s not enough to earn your keep in the NFL by playing.  Now you have to talk about it, too.

But not in the NBA, where players, coaches and owners are fined on a regular basis for saying the wrong thing (see Shaquille O’Neal, Phil Jackson and Mark Cuban, among others).  In pro sports, the policy is to see no evil, speak no evil, offer up plenty of platitudes:  As a team we really worked hard this week to…

Battery, the threat of bodily harm, is not free speech; in that regard, let the fines unfold.  Otherwise, why do I and the folks at ESPN get to say the refs stink, but not the people affected directly by their calls?  Why do I have First and Fifth Amendment rights but Marshawn Lynch doesn’t?  Because he’s an athlete rather than a suspect? 
Just for fun, Mark Cuban ought to challenge his next fine as a violation of his First Amendment rights.  That would be an interesting case to follow.  

No comments:

Post a Comment